The rapid mainstreaming of Artificial Intelligence (AI) has sharply expanded what EdTech products can do. EdTech products today generate instructional content, conduct assessments, deliver feedback, and tutor learners in real time. For India, this lands on a problem the country was already trying to solve. The National Strategy for Artificial Intelligence (NITI Aayog, 2018) names education as a priority sector and pins its two hardest constraints as scale, the sheer number of learners to reach, and distance, the gap between quality instruction and the learner who needs it. AI is attractive in India precisely because it can work on both at once, a system that explains, questions, and responds in a learner's own language. The opportunity is real, and it is arriving faster than the tools for telling good AI-powered products from weak ones.
That turns product selection into an evaluation challenge. A stakeholder used to be able to inspect an EdTech product before adopting it, its content and pathways were fixed and visible. An AI product cannot be judged that way: its instruction is generated live, so its quality shows only in how it behaves with a learner, never in the claim or the demo a policymaker, a school, or a parent is handed.
To address this, Tulna, housed at IIT Madras, traced how AI can be implemented in the design of learning products, what it now enables for learners, and what it puts at risk.
What AI Now Does in a Learning Product
- Automation: AI applied to well-bounded, repetitive tasks where a correct outcome is checkable.
- Adaptive and predictive personalisation: AI that uses learner data to sequence content, adjust difficulty, and recommend the next step.
- Generative AI: AI that produces explanations, worked examples, hints, feedback, even whole assessment items, composed live.
- Conversational AI: AI that engages a learner in multi-turn, natural-language dialogue, where the conversation itself is the medium of instruction.
Risks of AI-Mediated Learning
- In what the product puts in front of the learner: Covers pedagogical and interactional risks, where generated content, feedback, scoring, and dialogue can fail a learner.
- In the learner, over sustained use: Covers cognitive and psychosocial risks, where steady reliance on the system begins to affect how a learner thinks and develops.
- In the model underneath: Covers model- and training-level risks, where bias and error carried in the model surface in what a learner sees.
- In how the product is deployed: Covers implementation and governance risks, where data handling, silent updates, and unprepared oversight become the risk.